"Name That Bass"

The origin of this Bass is currently believed to be early English from the latter period of the 18th Century or early 19th Century. Several English authorities have guessed from the photos that it is from the English Midlands but at least one sees a possibilty of the Early London School of makers that used the Gamba form like George Corsby (c.1785-1800 or Corsby of Northampton c.1780) and Joseph Hill & sons (c.1765-1780s).

While the Restorer and the London dealers place its origin in England, some other American dealers and bassists have guessed from the photos that it is Bohemian or Central Europe from Germany thru Prague.

Recently I contacted a prominent Bass maker in Prague hoping he might shed some insight on his own school of makers and this is what he had to say from these exact same photos;

"As far as I can guess from the photos and dating (end of 18th or beg. of 19th century), this bass has nothing to do with the central European origin. This period in middle Europe was completely influenced either by Viennese makers like Posch (and their apprentices like Eberle, Willer) or by Saxony makers and their influence (Rauch family etc.)
The instrument on the photograph shows no similarities with any of these makers. I do not think there is any middle European influence on this bass"

According to his statement this rules out the Bohemian/Germanic theory and points us right back to Northern Europe's England or France.

A few other origin guesses besides French were American Prescott School and even Italy naming Gagliano as the possible maker. The Yankee guess was mainly from the old repairs that remain in the Bass currently and the Gagliano thought was inspired by the long FFs on the Bass. Never before have I seen the origin of a Bass guessed so broadly thru Europe as well as New England. I think that when the Bass is finally done and seen in person by some of these same people, we will get more agreement to a degree as to the origin of the Bass. So far, only the Restorer and myself have seen this Bass in person 'inside and out'.

This Bass is currently getting a complete restoration including internal Blocks cleaned and re-glued, Linings as needed & a Neck Graft as well as some cosmetic & structural repairs to last the next century. The Bass will be kept as original as possible with only the necessary replaced internal or external work. The existing 'Yankee' X-Brace and current small/low Bass Bar will actually remain as these are in perfect condition and holding up well doing the Job intended for at least the last 100-150 years. The restoration (started in 2004) is expected to be completed sometime in 2008.

I would like to point out that even though this restoration is in its 4th year, this slow-go acclimation process is actually favorable for a Bass that has been out of circulation and neglected for almost a century. This way, the Bass gets to settle in little by little under the watchful eye of a very skilled Luthier and treated accordingly. Many of the cracks and splits had to have the 'coal dust' cleaned out of them. The 'coal dust' being just one more sign of how long this Bass has been out of service and lying around in dis-repair. The Buckled Ribs are also being gradually straightened, glued and re-glued as the Bass returns closer and closer to its original form.

Patience must be on the 'menu' for any serious restoration projects such as this.


                  Top showing its graceful form and 'F' holes.

Note the bottom of the 'C' how is turns so softly towards the Lower Bout. This is one of the unusual features of this Bass that confuse the possible identity. The original Cross Bars/Rails are Gamba style construction. The Purfling on the Top is Northern European as used in England and France. The Back is not Purfled but has a few traces of 'inked' Purfling identified as 'English Ink'. The wood on the Back and Ribs is quartered Maple (or Sycamore) with narrow even flames. The current Neck Block is not original but is very old. There was a small piece of wood left glued to the upper Back near the current Neck Block which seems to be from the inner 'tab' of a Blockless style Neck. The upper Rib curve at the block however does not follow any of the typical Blockless forms we have seen. What we have here is a barrel full of Mysteries. Perhaps this was made as a Large Viol or Violone and was converted to a Double Bass sometime in the 19th century, first as a 3-string Bass and then fitted with 4-strings in the late 19th or early 20th century. The 4-gears however were from sometime in the 19th century as I have seen these on a few older Basses mainly German and English.


Full Sized Flatback of English Origin
Upper Bout: 22" Belly Length: 47" (45"- 46" after Block cut)
Center Bout: 15 3/8" String Length: about 42" w/Block Cut (was 44")
Bottom Bout: 28 1/2" Varnish: Golden Brown Oil
Rib Depth: 8 1/2" *
* Upper Bout tapers from 8 1/2" to 5 3/4" with slope of  the Back to the Neck Block. 
Top: 2-pc Spruce of extreemly fine grain (billet was about 15" wide with 300-350 growth rings).
Back & Ribs: 2-pc Highly Flamed quartered Maple of narrow width and evenly flamed.
The Maple Scroll, although varnished over in dark red is most likely original to the Bass as it matches in character as well. This Scroll was a 3-stringer originally as the plugs form the upper two gears were still visible. The Bass was mostly likely converted to a 4-string much later nearer the start of the 20th century. The Back of the Bass was also repaired sometime in the 19th century and possibly in New England as the 2nd set of Cross Bars were replaced with a single X-Brace without the customary 'lap-joint'. Scars from the original narrow rail-type Cross Braces are still visible and appear to be similar to the old English Gamba making school. A 3-string Maple Tailpiece (stained black with 2 holes added for 4 string) also came with this Bass when I bought it. This along with the Yankee style X-brace (without a lap joint) is further evidence that this Bass was in use or restored in USA in the early to mid 19th century. The Tuning Gears (set of 4 nearly matching each other) were either English or German as I have seen similar gears on at least 3 early 19th century Basses from both London and Mittenwald.

Before Carving After Carving
The Scroll was just decoratively re-Cheeked from the outsides to strengthen and beautify it with a similar looking piece of Flamed Maple from our aged Maple stock matching the character of the Back and Ribs. Between the Gear holes, screw holes and C-extension holes I plugged 72 individual holes of various sizes in the Scroll/Pegbox.

     Close ups of the 'F' holes and 'C' Bout can sometimes help identify the maker or exclude some as well.

This full view shows the proportions and the beautiful patina of an older instrument.

The Back has an added raised plate of wood that will be replaced with the same Maple as used on the Scroll.
The bottom of the Back will get a matching overlay Maple plate added for structure as well as cosmetics.

  Before: Right side Ribs showing numerous cracks to be repaired. 'After' photos to come when the restoration is done.

    Before: Left side Ribs showing numerous cracks to be repaired. 'After' photos to come when the restoration is done.
Th
These are some pictures of the Ribs disassembled as they undergo gradual repairs and straightening as some of them have buckled over time during its long state of dis-repair. Note the design of the Corner Blocks as the part touching the Lower and Upper Bouts are longer then the part of the Block touching the C-Bouts. This is a trait found in both old French and English Basses. Both the English and French have been known to use this feature of strengthening the Block-Joint as done in 18th and 19th century Furniture as well. This obtuse angled Corner Block also helps the joining of the softer angled lower Rib which is somewhat of a quasi-Guitar shape with its shallow bend.
Here we see a few more pieces as well showing the rather small sized Tailblock which will remain.

The 3-string Tailpiece (black stained Maple) shown was with the Bass when I acquired it. Although it is at least 150 years old I don't know if it is original to the Bass. The wear on the center 3-string hole shows that it was used as a 3-string for at least as long it was a 4-string. By the repairs and Gears I found on the Bass I would say it was a 4-string for about a 100 years. The new TP in Cocobolo made for this Bass by MPM may be put aside for use on another Bass in the future. I have 5 other classic Basses that have non-Ebony Tailpieces (stained black) and they each sound wonderful. I think this old 3-string TP will be more fitting than the new Compensating Pecanic TP. The 'Mojo' is something you just can't buy! The weight is another factor. The old 3-string weighs about 7.4oz (210gr) and the Cocobolo TP weighs 11.4oz (322gr). The lighter stained Maple actually sounds much deeper than the Cocobolo TP and has a slower decay to the tap tone (longer sustain) and the Cocobolo does not ring as much as the 3-stringer.
   Note the gentle bend of the upper back towards the neck block.  I have been told that this is a 'French' characteristic.

Copyright © 1998-2008  Ken Smith Basses, LTD.
(All rights reserved)
ALL PRICES AND SPECS SUBJECT TO CHANGE WITHOUT NOTICE